While it is sage advice to vote according to the values God reveals through Scripture, I think that “Vote God’s values!” is an oversimplification. Such a call seems to promote voting for a presidential candidate based on a moral checklist. If you’re going to vote like that, you might as well be voting for your senior pastor. He likely holds the same beliefs you do, which is why you’re attending the church where he preaches.
Let’s face it. At the end of the day, you’re voting for a politician to fill a secular office, not for a man to fill the role of a priest. Moore puts it gracefully –
Consequentially, that means we must take on much more care and responsibility with how we vote. We can’t merely skim through a lists of moral issues and vote for the candidate whose views align with ours. Take into account the candidate’s character, integrity, morality, and ability to run the office. Many preachers will encourage their congregation to neglect the last item. In which case, they should, quite literally, vote for their pastor.
And just as a fun little disclaimer before someone tosses a grenade my way, morality is indeed important. It simply don’t trump all other considerations.
[1] Theologians Tackle ‘Should Christians Vote for a Mormon for President?’ Question